“Equal justice under the law cannot be just a slogan. It must apply to everyone, including a United States senator.”
For Immediate Release November 19, 2026
CHARLESTON, W.Va. — West Virginia Democratic Party Chair Mike Pushkin today challenged U.S. Attorney Moore Capito, State Treasurer Larry Pack, and Republican Party Chair Josh Holstein to demonstrate that their recent declarations about accountability and equal treatment under the law apply to everyone, including U.S. Senator Jim Justice and his family's business empire.
In announcing the federal indictment of State Auditor Mark Hunt, Capito emphasized that the rules governing public office do not change based on personal relationships or political position. Treasurer Larry Pack similarly called for transparency and accountability, declaring that West Virginians deserve better from their elected officials. And Republican party chair Josh Holstein stated, “The West Virginia Republican Party holds every elected official to the same standard, regardless of party, and will continue to stand for honest, accountable government in the Mountain State.”
“We applaud those sentiments,” Pushkin said. “But it's one thing to say that nobody is above the law. It's another thing entirely to conduct yourself as though you actually believe it. If Moore Capito, Larry Pack, and Josh Holsetein are serious about equal justice and accountability, they need to explain why the extraordinary financial conduct of Jim Justice and his family's businesses has not been subjected to the same publicly demonstrated level of scrutiny that ordinary West Virginians have faced.”
In August, the West Virginia Democratic Party formally requested an investigation by IRS Criminal Investigation into more than $8 million in federal payroll-tax liens filed against businesses associated with Justice's Greenbrier resort. Those liens involved federal income taxes, Social Security taxes and Medicare taxes associated with employee payrolls.
Those liabilities were hardly the first financial controversy surrounding Justice and his businesses.
In 2025, Justice agreed to pay nearly $5.2 million in overdue personal taxes. His family's companies have also faced millions of dollars in additional state and federal tax liens and other debts. In 2024, The Greenbrier's employee health insurance fund reported that the resort was approximately $2.4 million behind in required contributions, raising concerns about workers' health coverage. The resort disputed allegations that employee contributions had been improperly withheld from the fund.
“Think about that,” Pushkin said. “We have a United States senator whose businesses have faced millions of dollars in unpaid taxes and allegations of failing to make required contributions for workers' health insurance. Yet we have seen no public indication that anyone responsible for those payroll-tax obligations has faced the same criminal enforcement measures that have been brought against ordinary West Virginia business owners for far smaller amounts.”
Pushkin pointed to the U.S. Attorney's own website, which documents federal prosecutions involving substantially smaller amounts of unpaid employment taxes.
In Charleston, Luther Hanson pleaded guilty to willfully failing to pay over employment taxes. He paid more than $146,000 in restitution and a $5,000 fine. Capito's office specifically highlighted this in a February 2026 press release celebrating its collection of more than $4.3 million through civil and criminal enforcement actions.
In Montgomery, business owner Steve Lopez was sentenced to 15 months in federal prison for failing to pay approximately $394,000 in employment taxes.
In Hurricane, Dean Dawson was sentenced to 18 months in federal prison for willfully failing to pay over employment taxes, with a calculated tax loss of approximately $525,000.
And two corporate executives, Daniel Hovis and Janice Hensley, received federal prison sentences in a case involving more than $630,000 in unpaid employment taxes.
“These are not hypothetical examples,” Pushkin said. “These are actual prosecutions documented by the United States Department of Justice. Ordinary West Virginians have been investigated, prosecuted, fined and sent to federal prison for employment-tax violations involving a fraction of the amounts reflected in the Justice family's recent tax liens.
“So the question for Moore Capito is simple: Is the Justice family being held to the same investigative and enforcement standards as everyone else? And if so, what assurance can be provided to the public without compromising any legitimate investigation?”
Pushkin added, “We are asking them to follow the evidence, determine who was legally responsible for these obligations, and apply the same standards they have applied to other West Virginia business owners. Wealth, political connections and a seat in the United States Senate should have absolutely nothing to do with that determination.”
Pushkin also challenged Treasurer Pack to apply his recent demands for accountability consistently.
“Larry Pack is right that West Virginians deserve transparency and accountability from their elected officials. But that standard cannot stop at Mark Hunt's doorstep. If Treasurer Pack believes accountability matters, he should be equally willing to demand a full accounting of the millions in unpaid taxes and other obligations associated with Jim Justice's businesses.”
The Democratic Party renewed its August request for an IRS Criminal Investigation to examine the Justice family's federal employment-tax liabilities and determine whether any criminal violations occurred and whether the same standards have been applied as in comparable prosecutions.
“Shakespeare wrote of 'sound and fury, signifying nothing,'” Pushkin concluded. “That's what these declarations about equal justice risk becoming if they are not backed up by action. Until the Justice family's financial conduct receives the same rigorous scrutiny and, where supported by the evidence, the same prosecution that ordinary West Virginians have faced, the words of these Republican leaders will ring hollow.
“There cannot be one standard of justice for the people who work at The Greenbrier and another for the powerful family that owns it. The law must apply equally to the employee, the employer and the United States senator.”
#